I agree with Jacek, its the reasoning and analysis that counts but always develop your own trade management and avoid over trading, just take the calls which make sense to you personally, dont let them spin you around in circles getting nowhere fast. I don't know whether AL actually trades himself, often doubt it.
I appreciate your reply. At least I know that it's not just me !
As you say, there is no 'magic bullet'. I was already starting to 'just treat a signal service like an advisory service to help identify opportunities which then you trade yourself.'
I still have issues with timing and patience and picking the right trades. However, I'm not losing money, just not making any !!!! When I say that I have probably executed more than 500 trades since I started 6 months ago, I must be making money - am just giving it to the broker. LOL.
I think you have helped me answer my own question. Instead of blindly entering trades, I am going to combine AL's ideas with some technical analysis and only when I get a confluence between the two will I enter a trade.
I think also that AL bases his trades on known fundamentals but sometimes market sentiment changes and this can have a profound impact.
Like last night for example, I nearly got stopped out EURJPY but I dropped my SL by 10 pips (don't normally do this but saw downside momentum had slowed seriously around 103.8) As a result I rescued it, and got out around breakeven. But I had to stay up late nursing it.
I also had a order setup for AL's short EURUSD but it never activated. AL's EURUSD short 'worked' because his lowest entry point was 1.3450 and the market only just spiked it. This is a great example where AL can say 'hit all targets' but many subscribers who set this up to automatically activate would probably have set the level higher than 1.3450 and missed the entry. If they were monitoring the market closely, they might have seen the market reverse and activate it manually at a price close to 1.3450.
I made up for it by managing a quick scalp of GBPUSD for the final 30 pips push up to 1.57.
Alan.. i found many problems with signal services like this one or even c3x..
it's all "smoke and mirrors" with entry and exit ranges and wide stops..
their success rate very much depends on these.. and in the case of c3x it's somehow always taken at best levels:-).. it rarely happens like that in live trading, unless you are very good and constantly monitoring your trades.. in which case you probably don't really needed a service like this..
only true test would be through a real time mirror trade like capability.. there are things like that eg. tradency.com or rentasignal.com but like with EAs their claims of greatness are rarely supported by actual live performance..
so basically there is no golden goose in trading.. unless your market maker or broker:-)
perhaps just treat a signal service like an advisory service to help identifying opportunities which then you trade yourself..
I wanted to ask forum members what tactics they use for picking their entry and exit levels for Premium trades......
I don't want to nurse my trades, just set and forget. However, the method I adopted (see below) consistently loses money ......
I was trying to go for Minimum risk (i.e. Short from the max price in the range or Long from the minimum price). I ended up catching too many trades that stop out. The other problem with this method is that I'm missing entries for profitable trades that are either trending in the right direction or trades that have entered the range and then reversed, before they hit the end of the range. What can I do to mitigate this? Enter 2 orders per trade, at each end of the range for half my overall position? Anybody got any suggestions?
Or is the best option to monitor the market and watch for technical signals where trades look like they are going to work - at which point jump in !!!! Obviously, this won't work with the set/forget idea..... The other problem is living in Oz, most of the action happens overnight, not easy to jump in at the right time !
Try publishing this in the UK weekend papers: Traders bet BankofEngland will raise rates to 6.25% --highest since 1… https://t.co/GWXrTEAk4R(1 year ago)
Poor start to a slow market day as Ezone PMIs disappoint. Im still keeping an eye on the rare (-2%) USD-GOLD combo,… https://t.co/UyRzWsRbs7(1 year ago)
-5% YTD is not good, while -7% from the year highs can be tough. Gold traders have their eyes fixated on this for n… https://t.co/NV5UMKsfNo(1 year ago)
ما وراء هبوط الدولار مع الذهب و من منهما يتمكن الارتداد؟
موعدنا الآن في غرفة شركة إكس أم لجلسة الأسواق
https://t.co/Y7tD0RxCS2
@XM_COM (1 year ago)
Jobless claims > 300k before next FOMC meeting would be ideal for Fed to make up for any CPI upside surprise (1 year ago)
"Cook & Eat at Home" scheme may come next to defeat UK inflation... (1 year ago)
Earlier in the week gold selloff was attributed to smaller than exp China EASING. Metal is now holding v well despi… https://t.co/ZW9cmXTPWW(1 year ago)
http://www.tradersandinvestorsclub.co.uk/video/audience-ashraf-laidi
login: ashraf
password: goldcrude
Ashraf
I appreciate your reply. At least I know that it's not just me !
As you say, there is no 'magic bullet'. I was already starting to 'just treat a signal service like an advisory service to help identify opportunities which then you trade yourself.'
I still have issues with timing and patience and picking the right trades. However, I'm not losing money, just not making any !!!! When I say that I have probably executed more than 500 trades since I started 6 months ago, I must be making money - am just giving it to the broker. LOL.
I think you have helped me answer my own question. Instead of blindly entering trades, I am going to combine AL's ideas with some technical analysis and only when I get a confluence between the two will I enter a trade.
I think also that AL bases his trades on known fundamentals but sometimes market sentiment changes and this can have a profound impact.
Like last night for example, I nearly got stopped out EURJPY but I dropped my SL by 10 pips (don't normally do this but saw downside momentum had slowed seriously around 103.8) As a result I rescued it, and got out around breakeven. But I had to stay up late nursing it.
I also had a order setup for AL's short EURUSD but it never activated. AL's EURUSD short 'worked' because his lowest entry point was 1.3450 and the market only just spiked it. This is a great example where AL can say 'hit all targets' but many subscribers who set this up to automatically activate would probably have set the level higher than 1.3450 and missed the entry. If they were monitoring the market closely, they might have seen the market reverse and activate it manually at a price close to 1.3450.
I made up for it by managing a quick scalp of GBPUSD for the final 30 pips push up to 1.57.
it's all "smoke and mirrors" with entry and exit ranges and wide stops..
their success rate very much depends on these.. and in the case of c3x it's somehow always taken at best levels:-).. it rarely happens like that in live trading, unless you are very good and constantly monitoring your trades.. in which case you probably don't really needed a service like this..
only true test would be through a real time mirror trade like capability.. there are things like that eg. tradency.com or rentasignal.com but like with EAs their claims of greatness are rarely supported by actual live performance..
so basically there is no golden goose in trading.. unless your market maker or broker:-)
perhaps just treat a signal service like an advisory service to help identifying opportunities which then you trade yourself..
I wanted to ask forum members what tactics they use for picking their entry and exit levels for Premium trades......
I don't want to nurse my trades, just set and forget. However, the method I adopted (see below) consistently loses money ......
I was trying to go for Minimum risk (i.e. Short from the max price in the range or Long from the minimum price). I ended up catching too many trades that stop out. The other problem with this method is that I'm missing entries for profitable trades that are either trending in the right direction or trades that have entered the range and then reversed, before they hit the end of the range.
What can I do to mitigate this? Enter 2 orders per trade, at each end of the range for half my overall position? Anybody got any suggestions?
Or is the best option to monitor the market and watch for technical signals where trades look like they are going to work - at which point jump in !!!! Obviously, this won't work with the set/forget idea..... The other problem is living in Oz, most of the action happens overnight, not easy to jump in at the right time !
Back to Chapter One then Oil fundamentals'
Topics dicussed; LIBOR spreads, EURUSD technicals & fundamentals, S&P500 cyclical patterns, gold dynamics, GBPCAD, GBPAUD, EURCHF, USDCHF & trading insights ahead of Friday's CANADA & US jobs reports.
DOWNLOAD WEBINAR HERE:http://www.hamzeianalytics.com/Educational_Webinars.asp
Ashraf
REGISTER HERE:
https://www1.gotomeeting.com/register/787802921
Ashraf
Free Admission
bit.ly/vmBOOT
Ashraf
i still expect AL bring his Real Time Tool next year, 3 months enough for developing.